In this post, we look at 7 of our favorite Tempur-Pedic alternatives. Tempurpedic mattresses are high quality mattresses – but they’re not for everyone.
Maybe you don’t like the feel of a Tempur-pedic bed. Maybe you don’t like the price tag and want a good night’s sleep at a lower price. Whatever the reason, check out our list of 7 alternatives below.
Ready to save (and sleep better)? Check the latest prices here:
- Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress – Check price
- Brooklyn Bedding Sedona Hybrid – Check price
- Keetsa Tea Leaf Supreme – Check price
- Tuft and Needle Mint Mattress – Check price
- Layla Memory Foam Mattress – Check price
- Nolah Evolution Mattress – Check price
- Saatva Coil Mattress – Check price
FYI: If you purchase an item based on a review on our blog, we may earn a small commission. If you return the purchase, we lose the commission. We recommend you only buy something if it seems like the perfect thing for you.
The Best Tempur-Pedic Mattress Alternative — Casper Nova Hybrid
Overall, one of our favorite alternatives to Tempur-Pedic is the Casper Nova Hybrid. This is a good alternative for people who like Tempur-pedic mattresses but just want something a little different, i.e. you liked your Tempur mattress but it just wasn’t “the right one for you.”
FYI: If you really don’t like the feel of a Tempur-Pedic and want something very different, check out the Tuft and Needle Mint Mattress (for an all foam bed) or the Saatva (for a coil mattress).
The Casper Nova Hybrid has:
- Zoned support – The parts of your body that weigh the most get more support.
- Breathable/ventilated foam that makes sure heat doesn’t get trapped in the bed
- Very soft top layers that provide cushion and comfort – think of this as the cozy layer.
- A sturdy and supportive base of innerspring coils. This is what helps keep your body aligned properly, helping you avoid back pain.
Plus, The Casper Nova Hybrid comes with a 90-day sleep trial, a money-back guarantee, and a 10-year warranty. Try the Nova Hybrid today risk free.
We also go into more detail on the Nova Hybrid below (including a breakdown of layers and materials), plus 6 more Tempur-Pedic alternatives.
1. Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress
First, the Casper Nova Hybrid is a very soft mattress. It’s very supportive but very soft. We recommend it for side sleepers of all sizes and back sleepers of a light build (think under 200lbs). If you’re a back sleeper who is heavier or you sleep on your stomach, you’d likely be better off with a firm mattress. If you need a firmer bed, skip down to our review of the Keetsa Tea Leaf Supreme.
The Casper Nova Hybrid is available in three different firmness levels: medium, medium-firm, and firm.
There are three main layers you need to know about:
- The first layer of the mattress is made with a comfy foam called “Hyper-Elastic Polymer,” which contours to your body shape and provides pressure relief. Pressure relief means you don’t really feel yourself up against the surface. For example, go lie down on the floor. The floor is sturdy, but there’s no pressure relief. You’ll feel agitated at your shoulders and hips. With the Nova’s “hyper-elastic polymer” you won’t get aggravation in those pressure points.
- The middle layer of the mattress is made with a transition foam that is designed to provide support and cushioning. A transition layer helps support the top layer, but also helps you from feeling the firmness of the bottom layer.
- Because this is a hybrid, the bottom layer of the mattress is made with pocketed coils. These coils provide structure and support. And because they’re pocketed, they help reduce noise (no creaking) and motion transfer (which is when you feel your partner moving throughout the night).
2. Brooklyn Bedding Sedona Hybrid
The Sedona Hybrid by Brooklyn Bedding is another hybrid mattress on our list. (Hybrid mattresses are pretty common as they give you the benefits of both a foam mattress and a coil mattress.)
The Sedona Hybrid is made up of 6 layers:
- The top layer is a cooling cover. The Sedona Hybrid uses a cooling fiber that helps your skin maintain ideal sleeping temperature (around 88 degrees).
- The second layer is a 1.5” layer of copper infused memory foam. Copper is also a cooling material, so this layer of memory foam won’t trap heat or sleep hot. And because it’s memory foam, you’ll get a soft cushion feel.
- The third layer is a smaller layer of micro wrappd coils. These micro coils are 2.5 inches tall.
- Then beneath those micro cools is layer of 1.5” of translation foam. This foam is very dense and is meant to provide a gentle translation between the layers of microcoils and the main base of coils at the very bottom of the mattress.
- The 5th layer is made up of individually wrapped coils. These coils offer edge support (where the edge of the bed is firmer/stiffer than the rest of the bed, which is great for sitting on the edge of the bed. Plus, the coils have zoned support, so they support you more in the parts of your body that tend to weigh the most.
- The last layer is just a base layer of foam – thin but firm, that helps keep the coils in place.
The Sedona Hybrid comes with a 120-day risk-free trial period. The mattress is also backed by a 10-year mattress warranty. Try the Sedona Hybrid today.
3. Keetsa Tea Leaf Supreme
The Keetsa Tea Leaf Supreme is an all-foam mattress. It uses both pressure-relieving memory foam, that takes the pressure off your body, in the top memory foam layers, and firmer, more rigid non-memory foam as the base layer.
The Tea Leaf Supreme uses some of the same technology as mentioned in the previous two beds, but it also has some unique qualities. For example, fiberfill fibers under the Linen Blend cover help minimize moisture when sleeping, ensuring a dry, but plush experience.
All Keetsa beds include a 12-year warranty. Keetsa ships its beds for free to 48 states (excluding Alaska and Hawaii).
4. Tuft and Needle Mint Mattress
The Tuft and Needle Mint mattress is going to feel very different than a Tempur-Pedic, or any mattress on this list because it doesn’t use memory foam.
So if you’re trying to get away from that cradling, contouring memory foam feel, then this is the mattress for you.
It’s going to be a little firmer, and rate higher in responsiveness – which basically means it bounces back more than any other mattress on our list.
This is a really good budget pick. Currently, at the time of this writing, the queen mattress is on sale for $1595, making it nearly $1000 cheaper than the Casper Nova Hybrid.
We recommend this mattress for back sleepers, light stomach sleepers and heavier side sleepers, or anyone who likes that firm to medium firm feel of a mattress.
5. Layla Memory Foam Mattress
The Layla Memory Foam is a special bed because it is essentially two beds in one. With both a soft and a firm side, you can flip to the kind of mattress you prefer. And, like all beds in this list, foam is used in the bed to ensure softness.
Something unique and generous about Layla is that they offer a lifetime warranty on their beds. Layla offers free shipping to the 48 contiguous states.
Layla offers a 120-night free trial for the Layla Memory Foam.
6.Nolah Evolution Mattress
The Nolah Evolution Mattress is another hybrid mattress, with Airfoam on the top layer and HDMax™ TriZone™ support coils below to maintain support. Three firmness options are available at checkout, making the Evolution a great bed for all kinds of sleepers; something to note though, the Evolution did win the Sleep Foundation award Best Mattress for Side Sleepers 2021.
At the time of writing, the Nolah Evolution is on a major sale. The Queen is going for $1,599 (normally $2,299) while the King is $1,799 (usually $2,499). A CaliKing is also available for the same price as the King. Nolah offers a gracious lifetime warranty for the Evolution.
The dimensions for the Queen Nolah Evolution Mattress are 60″W x 80″L x 15″H while the King dimensions are 76″W x 80″L x 15″H. It’s the tallest bed on this list. Nolah ships for free to the contiguous 48 states (per industry standard, as you’ve gathered from this article) and they ensure a 120-night free trial period for the Evolution Mattress.
7. Saatva
The Saatva coil mattress is made with a combination of foam and coils, and it has four main layers:
- The comfort layer of the mattress is made with a foam called “Euro pillow top,” which is designed to provide comfort and pressure relief.
- The second layer of the mattress is made with a layer of memory foam that is designed to contour to the shape of the body and provide additional pressure relief.
- The third layer of the mattress is made with a layer of polyfoam that is designed to provide support and cushioning.
- Saatva’s support layer is made with a layer of pocketed coils that are designed to provide structure and support. The pocketed coils are encased in foam, which helps to reduce noise and increase the overall comfort of the mattress.
What to Look for When Shopping for a Tempur-Pedic Alternative (a Simple Mattress Shopping Guide)
There are several reasons why you may not want a Tempur-Pedic, but what’s more important is how to figure out which mattress you do want.
To help you, here’s a simple guide of things to keep in mind as you shop.
Know the Different Mattress Firmness Levels
- Extra firm
- Firm
- Medium firm
- Medium
- Medium Soft
- Soft
- Ultra soft
Note: These might change slightly from mattress company to mattress company. For example, instead of an Extra Firm a mattress brand might use the language “ultra firm” and instead of a Medium Firm, they might say Luxury Firm.
Know the Main Mattress Types
- Innerspring mattresses – This is the traditional mattress that most of us slept on growing up, and that most of us sleep on when we visit hotels. It’s mainly using coils with a few inches of filling/padded layers on top of the coils. This may be foam, but doesn’t have to be. Coil mattresses are often more affordable, more bouncy, and some people just prefer them. But if you’re struggling with pressure points or sore back or tossing and turning a lot at night, we recommend you look at memory foam beds and hybrid beds.
- Memory foam mattresses – Memory foam mattresses are made from a type of foam called viscoelastic foam, which is a dense and soft material that is designed to contour to the shape of your body. Memory foam mattresses are known for their ability to conform to the body and provide pressure relief, making them a popular choice for people who experience pain or discomfort when sleeping on traditional innerspring mattresses.
Memory foam is made from polyurethane, which is a synthetic material that is made from petroleum. It is often treated with chemicals to increase its density and durability. Memory foam mattresses are typically composed of multiple layers of foam, including a top layer of viscoelastic foam and a bottom layer of denser foam for support.
One of the main benefits of memory foam mattresses is their ability to contour to the body and distribute weight evenly, which can help to reduce pressure points and increase comfort. They are also known for their ability to reduce motion transfer, making them a good choice for couples who share a bed. Memory foam mattresses are generally considered to be cooler than traditional innerspring mattresses, as they do not have metal coils that can conduct heat.
- Hybrid mattresses – Hybrid mattresses can be a good alternative to Tempur-Pedic mattresses for some people. Tempur-Pedic is a brand of memory foam mattresses that is known for its high level of comfort and support. Hybrid mattresses also offer comfort and support, but they use a combination of coils and foam rather than just foam.
One of the main benefits of hybrid mattresses is that they offer a balance of support and pressure relief. The coils in the base of the mattress provide a sturdy foundation and help to distribute weight evenly, while the foam layers on top contour to the shape of the body and provide cushioning. This can make them a good choice for people who want the benefits of both innerspring and foam mattresses.
Hybrid mattresses are also generally more breathable than pure foam mattresses, as the coils in the base allow for better airflow. This can help to keep the mattress cooler and more comfortable to sleep on. Hybrid mattresses are also often more durable than pure foam mattresses, as the coils in the base provide added support and structure.
Know Your Preferred Sleeping Position
Tempurpedic alternatives for side sleepers
Side sleeping is a common sleep position, and it can be beneficial for people who experience pain or discomfort when sleeping on their back or stomach. When choosing a mattress for side sleeping, it’s important to consider factors such as support, pressure relief, and comfort.
In general, mattresses that are able to contour to the shape of the body and provide pressure relief are a good choice for side sleepers. Memory foam mattresses are often a popular choice for side sleepers, as they are able to conform to the curves of the body and distribute weight evenly. Other types of foam, such as polyfoam and latex, can also be good options for side sleepers, as they are able to provide contouring and pressure relief.
Hybrid mattresses, which combine elements of both innerspring and foam mattresses, can also be a good choice for side sleepers. The foam layers on top of a hybrid mattress can provide contouring and pressure relief, while the coils in the base can provide support and structure.
Here are 2 good Tempurpedic alternatives for side sleepers:
- Purple: Purple is a brand of foam and hybrid mattresses that is known for its unique, gel-like foam that is designed to contour to the shape of the body and provide pressure relief. Purple offers a range of foam and hybrid mattresses in different firmness levels to suit different preferences.
- Casper: Casper is a brand of foam and hybrid mattresses that is known for its comfort and support. Casper offers a range of foam and hybrid mattresses in different firmness levels to suit different preferences.
Tempurpedic alternatives for back sleepers
- Saatva: Saatva is a brand of innerspring and hybrid mattresses that is known for its support and durability. Saatva offers a range of innerspring and hybrid mattresses in different firmness levels to suit different preferences.
- Leesa: Leesa is a brand of foam mattresses that is known for its comfort and support. Leesa offers a range of foam mattresses in different firmness levels to suit different preferences.
Tempurpedic alternatives for stomach sleepers
- Casper: Casper is a brand of foam and hybrid mattresses that is known for its comfort and support. Casper offers a range of foam and hybrid mattresses in different firmness levels to suit different preferences.
- Leesa: Leesa is a brand of foam mattresses that is known for its comfort and support. Leesa offers a range of foam mattresses in different firmness levels to suit different preferences.
For more information, check out our posts on:
